As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Honeywell Home RTH9585WF1004 Review: Wi-Fi Comfort on a Budget
My old thermostat was driving me crazy. It was one of those ancient programmable models with buttons so stiff you needed thumb strength worthy of a rock climber. The programming felt like solving a Rubik's Cube blindfolded, and I eventually gave up and just adjusted it manually every day. When my HVAC technician mentioned the Honeywell Home Wi-Fi model during a routine maintenance visit, I decided it was time for an upgrade.
What drew me to the RTH9585WF1004 wasn't just the promise of remote control—it was Honeywell's reputation for reliability. They've been making thermostats forever, and I figured if anyone knew how to build one that actually worked well, it would be them. The colorful touchscreen looked modern without being overly flashy, and the price point seemed reasonable for what it offered.
After three months of daily use through both heating and cooling seasons, I've found this thermostat strikes a interesting balance between smart features and straightforward functionality. It doesn't try to be overly clever with AI learning that might misinterpret your preferences, but it gives you all the tools to create the perfect climate schedule for your home.
Key Features & Specifications
- 7-day programmable scheduling with multiple periods per day
- Full-color touchscreen display with intuitive navigation
- Wi-Fi connectivity for remote control via smartphone app
- Works with Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant, and Apple HomeKit
- Energy-saving modes including geofencing capability
- Auto change from heat to cool mode as needed
- Filter change reminders based on runtime or days
- Alerts for extreme temperature conditions
- Compatible with most heating and cooling systems
- No C-wire required for many installations
Performance in Real Life
Where this Honeywell thermostat really shines is in its day-to-day reliability. The programming actually sticks—unlike my old unit that would randomly forget its schedule. I set up a weekday and weekend schedule during the initial setup, and it's been faithfully following it ever since.
During a recent cold snap, I appreciated being able to adjust the temperature from bed using the app rather than trudging downstairs to the hallway. The system responds quickly too—within about thirty seconds of making a change in the app, I can hear the furnace kick on. There's no noticeable lag that makes you wonder if your command went through.
The geofencing feature has saved me money on days when my schedule changes unexpectedly. I work from home most days, but when I need to go into the office, the app detects when I leave and can automatically set back the temperature. Coming home to a warm house without having wasted energy all day feels smart without being complicated.
What surprised me was how much I used the temperature alerts. During a particularly warm autumn day, I got a notification that the house temperature had risen above my cooling threshold. I was able to turn on the AC remotely before returning home, avoiding that stuffy, overheated feeling you get walking into a hot house.
Design & Build Quality
The first thing you'll notice is the vibrant color touchscreen. It's not just for show—the interface uses color intuitively. Blue backgrounds for cooling, orange for heating, and clear menu structures that make navigation simple. The display automatically dims at night to avoid being distracting, but brightens when it detects motion nearby.
Build quality feels substantial without being bulky. The white plastic frame has a slight texture that helps it blend with most wall colors, and it doesn't scream "tech gadget" in the way some smart home devices do. At about 1.5 inches deep, it sits flush against the wall and looks professionally installed.
The touchscreen responds well to finger taps without requiring hard presses. I've had no issues with unresponsive areas or ghost touches, which I've experienced with cheaper touchscreen devices. The physical buttons along the bottom provide quick access to temperature adjustment and menu navigation, offering a nice alternative to the touch interface.
My only minor complaint is that the screen can show fingerprints if you frequently adjust settings directly on the thermostat. It's easy enough to wipe clean with a soft cloth, but it's something to be aware of if you have young children who might touch the screen with sticky fingers.
Setup & Daily Operation
Installation was more straightforward than I expected. The included mounting plate made positioning simple, and the wire labels were clear enough that even someone with basic DIY skills could handle it. The step-by-step guide in the app walked me through each wire connection with helpful diagrams.
The initial Wi-Fi setup took about five minutes. The thermostat creates its own network temporarily to get your credentials, then connects to your home Wi-Fi. I've had no dropouts or connectivity issues, which is more than I can say for some smart devices in my home.
Programming the 7-day schedule is where this thermostat really excels. The touchscreen interface makes it simple to set different temperatures for wake times, leave times, return times, and sleep times. You can customize each day individually or copy patterns across multiple days. It's flexible enough for households with irregular schedules without being overwhelming.
The mobile app mirrors the thermostat's interface nicely. All the same settings are available, plus some additional features like energy usage reports and alert configurations. I find myself using the app about half the time and the physical interface the other half, depending on where I am in the house.
Special Features Worth Mentioning
The compatibility with all three major smart home ecosystems—Amazon Alexa, Google Assistant, and Apple HomeKit—is unusual at this price point. Many competitors pick one or two, but Honeywell covers all the bases. I tested it with both Alexa and Google Home, and voice commands worked reliably for basic temperature adjustments.
Auto changeover between heat and cool modes is brilliant for seasons with temperature swings. During fall, I set a temperature range rather than locking into one mode. The thermostat automatically decides whether to heat or cool based on the current temperature, which eliminates those days where you're constantly switching modes manually.
The filter change reminder is more useful than I anticipated. You can set it based on either days or system runtime, which gives a more accurate indication of when your filter actually needs changing rather than relying on calendar time alone. As someone who always forgets to change filters, this feature alone has probably improved my system's efficiency.
Weather information displayed on the home screen seems like a small thing, but I check it constantly. Seeing both indoor and outdoor conditions at a glance helps me decide how to dress before heading out, and whether I need to adjust the thermostat before leaving the house.
Energy Efficiency & Smart Features
While this isn't a "learning" thermostat that programs itself, the tools it provides for energy savings are comprehensive. The weekly energy reports show exactly how long your system ran each day and compare it to local weather conditions. Seeing this data visualized helped me identify patterns and adjust my schedule for better efficiency.
The smart response feature deserves mention—it learns how long your system takes to reach temperatures and starts early to hit your desired temperature right at your scheduled time. Waking up to a perfectly warm house without the system running all night is both comfortable and efficient.
I particularly appreciate the vacation mode. Setting a single energy-saving temperature for an extended period is simple, and the app reminds you to set it back to normal before you return home. During a week-long trip, I'm confident the system maintained temperatures that protected my pipes and plants without wasting energy.
Pros & Cons
Pros:
- Reliable performance with quick response to commands
- Excellent touchscreen interface that's intuitive to use
- Works with all major smart home platforms
- No C-wire required for many installations
- Comprehensive scheduling with flexible programming
- Useful alerts and reminders that actually help maintenance
Cons:
- Screen shows fingerprints easily with frequent touching
- App interface, while functional, isn't as polished as some competitors
- Geofencing requires leaving the app running in background
- Some advanced features require digging into submenus
Who Should Consider This Thermostat
This Honeywell model is perfect for homeowners who want smart features without the premium price tag. If you're comfortable setting up a schedule yourself rather than relying on AI learning, you'll appreciate the control and predictability it offers.
Renters might want to look elsewhere unless they have landlord permission, as it's a permanent installation. People with highly irregular schedules who prefer manual adjustments might not utilize the programming features enough to justify the cost.
Tech-savvy users will appreciate the broad compatibility with smart home systems, while those less comfortable with technology will find the physical interface straightforward enough for daily use. Families with consistent weekly routines can set it once and basically forget about it.
If you frequently forget to adjust your thermostat when leaving home or want better control over your energy usage, the Wi-Fi features and scheduling capabilities will quickly pay for themselves in comfort and savings.
Final Impressions
The Honeywell Home Wi-Fi Color Thermostat feels like the sensible choice in the smart thermostat market. It doesn't have all the flashy AI features of some premium models, but what it does, it does reliably and well. The interface strikes that rare balance between being powerful enough for tech enthusiasts and simple enough for anyone to use.
After living with it for several months, I've come to appreciate its no-nonsense approach to smart climate control. The scheduling works exactly as programmed, the app connects reliably, and the physical interface responds instantly when I walk up to it. Sometimes, dependable simplicity beats clever complexity.
If you're looking to upgrade from a basic thermostat without breaking the bank, this Honeywell model delivers solid performance and useful smart features that genuinely make life more comfortable. It's earned a permanent place on my wall—and in my daily routine.
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.